Sunday, September 24, 2017

On Schadenfreude

From Wikipedia:
Schadenfreude (/ˈʃɑːdənfrɔɪdə/German: [ˈʃaːdn̩ˌfʁɔʏ̯də]lit. 'harm-joy') is the experience of pleasure, joy, or self-satisfaction that comes from learning of or witnessing the troubles, failures, or humiliation of another.

More specifically, seeing someone "get what he deserves."  Some sort of cosmic revenge.  


Some examples:

  • A realtor recently reposted a meme on social media with a cartoon of a car hitting protesters (as in Charlottesville), with the caption "All Lives Splatter." The repost received a lot of attention because she is also a state legislator. The brokerage with which she was affiliated terminated their relationship. (Realtors are usually independent contractors, not employees, so headlines saying she was fired are inaccurate.)
  • A young man who makes very public statements of politically conservative views once tweeted that he shouldn't be required to have health insurance since he is young and healthy. He is now conducting a fundraising campaign to pay for medical bills after a serious car accident.  
  • There are countless cases of politicians or religious figures who espouse a highly conservative agenda (which almost always includes reversing or limiting the rights of LGBT people), who are revealed to have secretly indulged in extramarital affairs, sometimes with members of the same sex, and usually with a great deal of humiliation to their families and themselves. 


No one "gets what he deserves."  Yes, actions have consequences, some of them negative, but who are we to rejoice in anyone's misfortune?

I hope there are people who agree with me that celebrating negative outcomes is wrong. Just plain wrong. I think if someone is publicly disgraced, one's energy is better invested in sympathy than in trying to humiliate that person further. If a corporation is forced to end a relationship with an individual, I think a more appropriate feeling is concern for the individual and sorrow for the investment in time and energy on both sides.  

Perhaps the problem with my way of thinking is that it recognizes the humanity of the person suffering. Few of us are apathetic toward the misfortunes of people stricken with illness, of victims of natural disasters or poverty, toward the families of victims of violence. What I'm saying is that everyone deserves the same concern. 

I know it has been human nature to kick a man when he's down, as they say, for as long as humans have been able to kick. We are not as far removed from the savage, barbarian existence of our ancestors as we'd like to believe. But we are removed from it. Why can't we act like it?

(This article discusses Schadenfreude in slightly more scientific terms, although it's not an academic article. Note it states that people do not experience Schadenfreude equally, and makes suggestions about people who do experience it more frequently or strongly.)

Monday, September 11, 2017

On home rehab television shows

I was going to write a post about current events and politics, but I decided that was far too serious. Instead, I'll write about those renovation shows on cable TV.

The quintessential renovation show
HGTV.com
I love those shows. I love seeing the creativity, and seeing how a designing eye far better than mine can envision making a rough space beautiful. But I really must be realistic, nay, cynical--this is television. A lot of those scenarios are just silly. For example:
  • The last-minute surprise: Yes, surprises happen, and I realize that some complications can't be seen before demolition starts. But really, in every episode? Even when buying a house without an inspection--or worse, sight unseen--what sort of businessman sets a budget without knowing for sure whether he has to replace a roof or an HVAC system? What sort of flipper doesn't just assume a 100 year old house will need all-new electrical and plumbing systems? Who continues to use a contractor who paints the walls with the trim color and the trim with the wall color, or who installs the master bathroom tile in the hall bathroom and vice versa? Wouldn't a home owner want to see a detailed scope of work, project plan, and budget, including contingencies?
  • The budget vs. design debate: Again, the initial plan should include design, budget, and allowance for contingencies. Yes, design changes happen once things start to pan out, and yes, clients often add requests to the scope, but good planning up front and properly managed expectations and boundaries make for a smoother renovation.
  • The decision on which property to buy and fix up: We know that on most of these television shows that include a decision between properties, the decision has already been made before production begins on the episode. Often the home is in contract or the "clients" already own the house.  
  • The unrealistic budgets and schedules: Complete living room/kitchen/bath renovation for $25,000, in two weeks? Really?  
Another very popular renovation show
HGTV.com
I love these shows anyway. I love it when the home owner cries upon first sight of her new home. I love the supposed follow-up scenes showing the families in the new homes, almost always entertaining friends and talking about how wonderful the new house is. I love the wacky shows like Texas Flip and Move (DIY Network) just as much as the popular hits Fixer Upper and Flip or Flop (both HGTV).

Some shows are more successful than others in my eyes, some "stars" more likable, but I still like most of the shows. I hope renovation and house flipping shows continue to be popular. I hope television people continue to think of clever new ways to portray home renovation.